Measuring thread quality seems to be one hundred percent stepping over a line to me. I have never seen a game try doing that before, and I hope to never have to. Especially a game I love.
I'd prefer a system that just says here are the things that count for AC: whether that be a post, log, thread of x-number of comments (JUST PICK A NUMBER and leave it at that), and you need so many of these things COMBINED a month to pass. Don't say 'on a case by case basis' we may change this. Don't judge the quality of any of those things.
If someone's really abusing a system like THAT? Talk to them privately.
It's easy. It works for lots of other games. It could work here too.
no subject
I'd prefer a system that just says here are the things that count for AC: whether that be a post, log, thread of x-number of comments (JUST PICK A NUMBER and leave it at that), and you need so many of these things COMBINED a month to pass. Don't say 'on a case by case basis' we may change this. Don't judge the quality of any of those things.
If someone's really abusing a system like THAT? Talk to them privately.
It's easy. It works for lots of other games. It could work here too.